|
by Bill Lichtenstein
I am a documentary producer, a journalist who has made a living out of
helping people tell their stories. I did it for more than 20 years before
I got sick.
I worked as an investigative reporter, including seven years at ABC News
where I produced segments for 20/20, Nightline, and World News Tonight.
I did stories about organized crime connections to the Reagan administration,
abused children in state juvenile institutions and exploding automobile
gas tanks. Then, in 1986, my own world exploded.
The symptoms of my manic depression were classic: overwhelming energy,
extreme euphoria, racing thoughts, irritability, months of depression.
I searched through many doctors and a hospitalization for someone who
could explain what was happening to me. For years, no one could.
Finally a psychiatrist at McClean Hospital in Boston made the proper
diagnosis, put me on medication, and gave me back my life. To understand
that what was happening to me was a result of an illness an illness that
was readily treatable offered great comfort. But I had so many questions
that remained unanswered.
What had caused it? Did it result from something I did, some aspect of
my lifestyle or upbringing? Would medication change me deprive me of the
spark and creativity that were a part of me and critical to my work as
a journalist? Was my experience with the illness unusual? Could I stop
'taking the medicine, and control the illness with sheer willpower? What
about close friends and co workers who did not understand manic depression
and had distanced themselves from me? How could I communicate to others
what this extraordinary roller coaster ride had been like? Would they
ever understand what I had gone through?
I was one of 1.5 million Americans with manic depression, but I felt
all alone.
Having lived with the symptoms of manic depression for so long, I'd
come to believe that they were part of me...
It's the problem virtually everyone with mental illness faces. It's not
that people around me didn't care. They just didn't understand why I had
changed so dramatically, becoming unpredictable, confused and sometimes
difficult. Before they would be able to reach out to me with empathy,
support and compassion, they needed to understand what I had gone through.
For me, that meant learning to tell my story, and I did that by helping
others to tell theirs. Over the past five years, my company, Lichtenstein
Creative Media, Inc., has produced a series of one hour radio documentaries
called "Voices of an Illness," featuring firstperson accounts
of people describing what it's like to live with and recover from manic
depression, depression and schizophrenia.
Following my diagnosis, I started my search for answers where most people
would begin at, the bookstore. I looked for anything that might provide
insight into living with and recovering from the illness. There was nothing.
(At the time Patty Duke's inspiring book "A Brilliant Madness: Living
with Manic Depressive Illness" which details her struggle with the
mood disorder had not yet been written, nor had Kathy Cronkite's remarkable
"On the Edge of Darkness.") Furthermore, film and radio documentaries
about mental illness focused primarily on people in the throes of the
disorders, with dramatic and often frightening pictures of symptoms but
little sense of what the people felt inside. Those in the midst of a mental
illness are in no condition to describe their experience in a thoughtful,
compelling or insightful manner, nor offer hope for recovery.
In the absence of any book or documentary that could help me, I decided
to create my own, and developed "Manic Depression: Voices of an illness,"
narrated by Patty Duke, the 1992 radio documentary which was to become
the first in the Voices of an Illness series.
The initial $400 in seed money for the program came in the summer of
1990 from members of the Manic Depressive and Depressive Support Group
of New York, in $10 and $20 contributions. With the help of Bob Boorstin,
who had also recovered from manic depression (and has since gone on to
work in the White House) I wrote and circulated a one page funding proposal
to potential underwriters national mental health groups, foundations,
concerned individuals and pharmaceutical companies. The support came quickly.
Within two months, I had raised most of the money for the two year research
and production of the program.
I found people around the country who had recovered from manic depression
professional people, including a Fortune 500 executive, a therapist, a
registered nurse, a financial advisor and a salesman. They described in
detail every aspect of the illness's effect on their lives from its onset
through their recovery. I also was extremely fortunate to gain assistance
from top mental health clinicians, researchers and advocates, including
Dr. Frederick K. Goodwin, Dr. Robert Post, Dr. William Potter and Dr.
Elliot Gershon, all of the National Institute of Mental Health; Dr. Kay
Jamison of Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and Laurie Flynn
of the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill. They were generous with
their time, answered questions ranging from the simplistic to the philosophical
and helped provide a broader context about the medical and social aspects
of the illness. On a personal level, it was like having the world's largest
support group.
Having lived with the symptoms of manic depression for so long, I'd come
to believe that they were part of me: that the short attention span was
a character flaw, that irritability was a function of personality, and
that the overwhelming energy level was "just the way I was."
It was hard for me to understand and accept that many of the effects of
manic depression were, in fact, symptoms. The people with manic depression
and the doctors validated my experiences with the illness. When computer
programmer Joe Valencik talked about hypomania, he could have been talking
about me:
"Normal people have this thing called adrenaline that comes on
and off and it's a switch. So when they come into a situation like I
am in now, with this interview, it comes up and they get this buzz.
And they feel it, and they're pumped up, and that's the normal, healthy
way. And then it goes away, you know, when they leave. But for people
that have the illness and are in that hypomanic stage that doesn't go
away, it's just there. It's there when you go to sleep and you're trying
to close your eyes and sleep, but your thoughts are still going. You
can't even sleep."
Producing the show, I first learned of the relationship between manic
depression and creativity from Dr. Kay Jamison's work. It was inspiring
to know that far from being doomed by the illness, it actually has positive
aspects. In a 1990 speech, she talked about the symptoms:
"It's kind of like who wouldn't want this disease? Right? I mean,
you are talking about decreased need for sleep, more energy than usual,
inflated self esteem, increased productivity, This Is my favorite one
here sharpened and unusually creative thinking. This is listed as a
symptom of psychopathology. Uninhibited people seeking hypersexuality.
It's hard to come out against any o f these things, 1 mean. And the
question is, you know, who wouldn't want it? How can you bottle it?
How can you sell it?"
Would medication change me deprive me of the spark
and creativity that were a part of me and critical to my work as a journalist?
Was my experience with the illness unusual? Could I stop taking the medicine,
and control the illness with sheer willpower? What about close friends
and co workers who did not understand manic depression and had distanced
themselves from me? How could I communicate to others what this extraordinary
roller coaster ride had been like?
Although my own personal experiences with the social stigma attached
to the illness were not as severe or dramatic as those of school teacher
Mike Mayfield, his experiences with his girlfriend's family touched a
nerve:
"You know, I came to the window and the first to arrive at our
townhouse was Mary's mother. Moments later, Mary's father arrived. Two
minutes later, Mary was out the door, engaged in a big argument with
both her mother and her father. And 1 looked out, you know, to the neighborhood
and people were coming to the doors. The voices had grown so loud that
I could hear, Berserker! Berserker! You know, You're living with a madman,
Mary! What are you doing? You know, 'He's unsafe. It's unsafe for your
children, unsafe for you.' You know, Leave him!"
Producing the show was tremendously empowering and validating. I began
to feel I was not alone, either in what I had gone through while I was
ill or in my personal struggles with the social stigma of the illness.
The response to the show was overwhelming. Tens of thousands of listeners
called seeking help and support from the national mental health groups
whose phone numbers we provided at the end of the show. National Public
Radio audience services reported an "unprecedented listener response."
One woman called a radio station to say she was in her car on her way
to take her own life, heard the show, and decided to seek help instead.
We also received a call from an underwriter who suggested a second show,
on schizophrenia. The timing was right. A new generation of medications
was allowing hundreds of thousands of people previously untreatable to
return to their daily lives.
In 1994, "Schizophrenia: Voices of an Illness," narrated by
Jason Robards, detailed the often incomprehensible symptoms and social
stigma associated with the thought disorder. For people with schizophrenia
and their families, the program let them know they were not alone with
the mysterious and often terrifying symptoms of the illness. Laura Young,
who today is an art therapist, described the onset of her schizophrenia,
which as often happens, came on suddenly:
"I was walking across the campus at Yale in spring of my freshman
year, and I was looking up at the sky, and suddenly it cracked like
a mirror into thousands of pieces. I don't know why I didn't realize
that that was an incredibly strong signal that something was wrong with
my head and that 1 needed help."
The show tried to demystify one of the most frightening aspects of the
illness hearing voices. Murray Frances described her symptoms in extraordinary
detail:
"I heard a woman's voice and I no longer remember exactly what
she said, but it was something like: 'I want you to know that you have
been chosen. You are select, you are special. We're going to take care
o f you. We're going to give you great powers. We are a group of very
important Lords, and we are going to make you a special person. You're
not like any mortal on this earth. You're going to save the earth, in
fact.' And... there it is! Which sounds nuts, and was! I didn't tell
anyone any of this. Nobody knew, my parents certainly didn't know. And
I remember that feeling of being absolutely apart and different, and
not like this family I'd grown up in, that now had suddenly become strangers."
For Murray Frances and thousands like her, new medications meant the
difference. Today, she has graduated from medical school and is a psychiatrist
working with people with schizophrenia.
The power of the show, in large part, was due to the fact that these
people had never before told their stories. No one had ever asked them
to describe what the illness felt like even though some of them were ill
and in treatment for decades. In fact, one leading doctor who treated
a woman for seven years said he was totally unaware of his patient's extraordinary
experiences. For her, it was a relief to finally talk about what she'd
gone through. For the listening audience, it provided a window on this
most misunderstood thought disorder.
The third show in the Voices of an Illness series is on depression. It
will be narrated by Rod Steiger, and will air in the fall of 1995 on NPR
stations across the country. "Depression: Voice of an Illness"
will focus on the mood disorder which affects one out of six Americans,
and twice as many women as men.
Although the onset and symptoms of the illness are not as dramatic as
those of schizophrenia and manic depression, the sheer numbers of people
suffering from the wide variety of clinical depressions make it a program
that can touch a far greater audience.
The show will highlight that clinical depression is a diagnosable biochemical
illness which is different than sadness or the blues and that it is readily
treatable. Eighty five percent of people with clinical depression can
recover. The program will also feature new clinically tested medications
and talk therapies shown effective in treating depression. By doing so,
the documentary will hopefully help lift the national shroud of shame
surrounding
Following my diagnosis, l started my search for answers where most
people would begin at the bookstore. I looked for anything that might
provide insight into living with and recovering from the illness. There
was nothing. (At the time Patty Duke's inspiring book "A Brilliant
Madness: Living with Manic Depressive Illness" which details her
struggle with the mood disorder had not yet been written, nor had Kathy
Cronkite's remarkable "On the Edge of Darkness:')
the illness, and encourage those affected to seek treatment. Again, people
who have recovered from the illness form the basis for the show.
If these programs have proven anything, it is the extraordinary power
of a simple story. Thus far, the series has won 15 major broadcast and
mental health awards. I was pleased when Time Magazine called the schizophrenia
program " a remarkable documentary," in an article which ran
under the headline "The Souls that Drugs Saved' opposite a story
exposing Dr. Peter Breggin's attack on medication therapy.
In May, the schizophrenia show received the 1994 George Foster Peabody
Award for Excellence in Broadcasting, television and radio's highest honor.
But most important is the fact that the programs have provided a life
line: tens of thousands of listeners have responded with calls for help
that were answered by the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill, the
National Mental Health Association, the National Depressive and Manic
Depressive Association, the National Alliance for Research on Schizophrenia
and Depression, the National Foundation for Depressive illness and their
more than 2,000 local affiliates across the country.
The general public more often than not sees mental illness in the form
of those who are ill on the streets or in the media. Those who have recovered
and are in the best position to speak out usually don't, fearing the stigma
attached to these illnesses. But, once others can understand, they are
in a better position to offer assistance, support, empathy and compassion.
As Mike Wallace said in Kathy Cronkite's book, On the Edge of Darkness:
"People who don't know [what depression is], who say it's selfindulgence,
sound callous, but it's not callousness born of indifference; I think
it's callousness born of ignorance. That kind of ignorance we've got
to get rid of, and little by little 1 suppose, we will. You say to them,
It's a pity you don't know. I'm sure that if you knew, I'm sure that
if you knew, not only wouldn't you say that, you'd try to help in one
way or another."
For myself and those who participate in the documentaries, it is empowering
to speak out about mental illness. It helps provide validation, hope and
the means to recover. Not to speak out is to live a lie, in the closet.
By speaking out about your own experiences, it
empowers all of us, and helps break down stigma. It is the most powerful
action any of us can take. Add your voice and tell your story.
(This article was first published in 1995, in The Journal of California
NAMI)
BILL LICHTENSTEIN is a media professional who lives and works in New
York.
|